Furlough Fraud – Now just 60 days to self-report any potential abuse of the support scheme or face personal liability, HRMC action and potential criminal action.

Do not make recession your obsession, just remember to forget it and you’ll be ok

Mina Tadros
Furlough Fraud – Now just 60 days to self-report any potential abuse of the support scheme or face personal liability, HRMC action and potential criminal action.
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

By Steven Mather, Solicitor

While the Government’s financial schemes have been a real help to many businesses during the coronavirus pandemic, fraudsters are quick to find ways to take advantage. The Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (CJRS), known as the Furlough Scheme, is no exception and along with other financial support such as the Business Bounce Back Loan Scheme (BBLS), they are opening up a whole new risk of prosecution to business owners. Steven Mather, a commercial lawyer with Nexa Law, writes. 

The news recently reported that HMRC arrested a West Midlands businessman as part of an investigation into a suspected £495,000 Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme fraud. Although he was also arrested on the basis of tax fraud and money laundering offences, HMRC said it was the first arrest in respect of furlough fraud. 

As of the 9th August, 9.6 million jobs had been furloughed at a cost of £34.7 billion (source) and we’re informed by HRMC that there have been over 8,000 reports of so called Furlough Fraud. Furthermore, a report from economists at the universities of Cambridge, Oxford and Zurich have identified that 87% of men and 77% of women who received a salary top up continued to work for their employer while on furlough even though work is expressly prohibited by HMRC rules. Among those workers who didn’t receive a top up, 69% of men and 52% of women routinely ignored this prohibition. Overall, 63% of furloughed people revealed they had spent some time working for the employer that had furloughed them, yet only 22% of furloughed men and 17% of furloughed women say they were formally asked by their employer to work. 

If we take those stats and extrapolate them, approximately 1.9 Million employees were asked to work in breach of the scheme rules. My rough calculations would suggest that is some £6 BILLION of Furlough Fraud that has been committed. 

There’s a few issues which I’ve seen which is likely to amount to “furlough fraud” such as: 

– Furloughing staff and not paying them the full 80% under the scheme, so for example only paying 60-70% of usual pay and pocketing the rest. 

– Employers making backdated claims that include periods in which the employee was not working.

– Pretending to hire staff (ghosting) in order to take advantage of the support payments.

– Asking employees to work, whether as a ‘volunteer’ or ‘paid on the side’ or in order to get their wages ‘topped up’ to 100%

– Furloughing staff (without their knowledge) while they continue to work as normal

– Using the payments to pay for redundancy pay

It is not just the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme that is subject to fraud though. The ease of obtaining Bounce Back Loans is likely to make it attractive to fraudsters (or even just to naïve business owners). An insolvency practitioner I work with has already seen a number of frauds which have been reported where the bounce back loans were used inappropriately including: 

– A restaurant where they received £50K, promptly repaid family loans (leaving other suppliers and HMRC behind) and have decided not to re-open.

– A director received the £50K and has purchased a luxury car for his personal use.

– One director has a group of 5 companies and applied for the loan on each company. Upon receipt of the loan funds, he withdrew the lot (ie £250K) and redeemed his residential mortgage

Indeed it could be that the BBL scheme was applied for fraudulently in the first place, even if funds were then properly used. This could be, for example: 

– Falsifying trading turnover when applying to borrow more than you would otherwise be entitled to.

– Not declaring the business was in trading difficulties on December 31st 2019 – a key point of the facility, which is to support otherwise viable businesses struggling with COVID 19, not prop up already failing ones.

– Using the funds for a purpose other than for the benefit of the business. This may be for a personal asset or for a property purchase. 

What happens if a business has committed coronavirus support scheme fraud? 

The Government brought forward legislation specifically to address inspection, investigation and prosecutions for misuse of the various coronavirus support schemes. The new legislation gives HMRC rights such as:

– ensuring HMRC can use its information and inspection powers to check coronavirus support claims have not been overpaid and that a CJRS payment has been used to pay furloughed employee costs

– giving HMRC powers to raise an Income Tax assessment on anyone who has received a SEISS or CJRS payment to which they are not entitled, or anyone who has not used a CJRS payment to pay furloughed employee costs. Penalties will be 100% of the sums incorrectly claimed.

– giving HMRC powers to charge a penalty where a person deliberately makes an incorrect claim for a SEISS or CJRS payment. It also gives HMRC powers to charge a penalty where a person who has claimed a CJRS payment deliberately does not use it for the costs it was intended to reimburse. The penalty will only apply if the person fails to notify HMRC about the situation within 30 days, or 30 days after the Finance Bill receives Royal Assent if it arose before that (currently this looks like it might become a 90-day window).

– giving HMRC powers to make a company officer jointly and severally personally liable for the Income Tax charge raised in relation to any CJRS payment to which the company was not entitled or any CJRS payment which was never intended to be used to pay furloughed employee costs in certain circumstances. Those circumstances are where the officer is culpable for making a deliberate CJRS claim to which the company was not entitled.

This is embedded within the Finance Act 2020, Schedule 16.  

This new legislation is of course supplementary to existing legislation for tax fraud such as: 

  • Conspiracy to defraud; a common law offence – Maximum: 10 years’ custody. Sentencing range: Low level community order – 8 years’ custody.
  • Fraud Act 2006 (section 1) statutory offence – Maximum: 10 years’ custody. Sentencing range: Low level community order – 8 years’ custody.
  • Cheating the public revenue; a common law offence – Maximum: Life imprisonment. Sentencing range: 3 – 17 years’ custody.
  • Criminal Finances Act 2017 – liability for corporates for the offence of failing to prevent tax evasion.

There is a 90 day grace period to report potential wrong doing, so if you are  business owner and are concerned about the situation, then you may want to take legal advice and may wish to self-report to HMRC before the 21st October 2020. 

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Steven Mather is a business lawyer with national firm Nexa Law. He specialises in advising businesses on legal risk, contracts, employees and disputes. His website can be found at www.stevenmather.co.uk. He also advises on redundancies and settlement agreements. 

More about Business Management...

What is this 'culture' thing anyway? And what does it mean for small businesses? ybkbs small b business news and features

What is This “Culture” Thing, Anyway? (And What Does it Mean for Small Businesses?)

Chances are, if you follow business news at all (and we assume you do if you’re reading this platform!) you will have heard a lot about Brewdog in the last couple of weeks. 

Without rehashing the whole situation, here’s an executive summary: dozens of former employees signed an open letter accusing the craft beer firm and its co-founder James Watt of fostering a “culture of fear.” Ex-staff members claim they were bullied, treated like objects, and that the company’s culture was “toxic.” You can read more in this excellent piece by Kalyeena Makortoff and Rob Davies for The Guardian.  But following this sage got me thinking: what is this “culture” thing we hear so much about, why does it matter, and how does it pertain to small business owners? 

Lockdown Extended. What Now for Small Businesses, the Self Employed and Hospitality? YBKBS Small Business News for smart business owner

Lockdown is Extended. What Now?

Yesterday, 14th June, the Prime Minister confirmed that the current lockdown restrictions (with some small exceptions) will be extended through until at least the 19th July. This is unlikely to be welcome news to many people. Most of us were looking forward to returning to full normality next week, and now have to wait a little longer. So what now for the self employed and small business owners?

Calls For The Right To Disconnect - A message to the self employed? - YBKBS Small Business News for Smart Business Owners

Calls For The Right To Disconnect – A Message To The Self Employed?

Employees are finally getting what many self employed business owners have almost taken for granted – working from home. But there is a growing realisation for the employees and employers that will not only be familiar to the self employed small business owners, but what potentially happens next could effect them for years to come.

When is it he right time to quit? YBKBS Small Business News for smart business owners

When Is It Time to Quit?

“Don’t quit” is popular advice for anyone who is trying to start or grow a business (or, frankly, achieve any other goal.) And I think it’s good advice… up to a point. Giving up too quickly or not persevering through difficulties is pretty much a guarantee of failure. Setbacks are a part of life, and certainly a part of business.  But when is there a right time to quit?

How to Support Your Team as We Come Out of CoVid - ybkbs small business news platform for the smart business owner

How to Support Your Team as We Emerge from the Pandemic

None of us have lived through anything like this before (and hopefully we never will again!) 

What does this mean for your business? It means that you need to make a conscious effort to support your staff as the pandemic ends and beyond. Many of them will have struggled over the last year, including in ways that you can’t see and won’t necessarily know about. 

Here are a few of our top tips to help you do right by your people. 

ecommerce simple steps to embrace it for small businesses and the self employed your best kept business secret small business news for smart self employed business owners

E-commerce: Simple Steps to Embrace It In Small Business

Some say everything needs to be online. And they have led you to believe that everything is now actually online and you won’t succeed unless it is. Yet, as we look across the business landscape at how customers and clients are coming back to businesses, there is still a very healthy demand for face to face contact and relationship building. So the sensible and and logical thing to do is to build a business that can offer both.


COVID’s Lasting Small Business Changes (and Why They Can Be Good News)

COVID has brought big changes to the world of small business. Learn why we don’t think they’re all (necessarily) bad news.

Half of Staff Like The Work /Life Balance - Double Trouble for Small Businesses YBKBS Small Business News for Smart Business Owners

Half of Staff Like The Work/Life Balance – Double Trouble for Small Businesses

Do you run a small business that employs staff currently working from home?
How are they doing?
Do you know what they’re doing when they’re meant to be working for you?
Is this the way you see the future of your business?

Well according to one survey, nearly half of employees think they’d rather quit their job than work in the ‘office’ again.